Connect with us
Advertisement
Advertisement

News

Outcry over NRW plans ‘led to consultation’

Published

on

Myherin: Not suitable for a leased shoot (Pic. geograph.org.uk)

AN ANIMAL rights organisation has claimed that controversy over NRW plans to to lease land it owns in Ceredigion to commercial shoots for game birds has led to a public consultation over the future of shooting rights on the body’s land. 

NRW leases five current areas of public land to commercial game shoots and those leases were not entered into by NRW, but by its predecessor bodies (Countryside Council for Wales, Environment Agency Wales and the Forestry Commission Wales). However, in addition to the five leases it inherited, NRW has sought to lease two additional sites for game shooting in Ceredigion: in the Tarenig and Myherin forests near Devil’s Bridge.

The birds involved would be pheasants, farmed elsewhere on a rear and release system for sports shooting.

Leaked internal NRW documents, including memoranda, criticise the proposed lease of Myherin Forest.

Nick Young, NRW Conservation Manager, wrote: “My considered opinion is that Myherin is not suitable for a leased shoot as things stand, and that any intention to take this proposal forward should require wider NRW and partner body consultation and an Ecosystem Appraisal of the likely effects of these shooting lease proposals.”

Peter van-Velzen, Programme Manager, said: “In my view the financial, employment and environmental impacts to harvesting by letting shooting rights here, will far outweigh the monetary income generated by a let. I note that no financial comparison has been carried out as part of this exercise.”

Nick Young also challenged a claim that the land earmarked for shooting was in ‘inconsistent use’ by the public. He pointed to Nantsyddion Bothy, which ‘is currently leased/loaned to the Mountain Bothies Association and is well used by walkers and well maintained at no cost to NRW. It forms part of a chain of bothies through Wales and often used in conjunction with Nant Rhys in Tarenig. Both Nant Rhys and Nantsyddion are well used’.

‘Does NRW really want the negative publicity of evicting MBA in favour of creating a shooting lodge?’

Animal Aid claims that NRW kept lease agreements ‘secret’ from the public and has launched a petition calling for ‘an end to ‘sport shooting’ on public land’. The text of the petition goes on to claim that ‘a properly conducted, independent and stakeholder-inclusive review should come to the conclusion that shooting should be banned on Welsh public land’.

The organisation also states that: “To ensure high stocks of pheasants on shoot days, NRW’s shoot tenants eliminate foxes, stoats, weasels, corvids and rodents.”

Last week, The Herald featured a story regarding one private shoot landowner’s campaign against the reintroduction of pine martens to the woodlands of Mid and West Wales.

A spokesperson for the British Association for Shooting and Conservation (BASC) explained to The Herald that BASC data does not separate out NRW land from other land upon which shoots take place in Wales.

They went on to say: “Shooting in Wales supports almost 2,500 full time jobs throughout the supply chain. This equates to £64m per year spent in Wales by shoot providers and participants annually. Shooting in Wales has been estimated to provide Gross Value Added of £75 million to the UK economy and can be an important source of income outside of traditional tourism periods. BASC, therefore, believes that shooting makes a significant contribution to the public estate.”

NRW were unable to provide The Herald with a start date for the consultation, as it is still finalising the arrangements, but the work will be finished in 2017.

Chris Tucker, Forestry Advisor for Natural Resources Wales who is leading the review, said: “One of our roles is to make the most of the land we manage on behalf of Welsh Government to benefit people, economy and the environment in Wales.

“Part of this work is the shooting rights we lease to third parties which have detailed plans to prevent harm to wildlife and the environment.

“We are carrying out a formal review of our policy on shooting on the land we manage, including activities by third parties, and this will include a consultation with the public to get their views.”

A Welsh Government spokesperson told us: “Natural Resources Wales is currently carrying out a review of its policy on shooting on NRW owned and managed land. The Welsh Government will be consulted during the review to ensure the review itself addresses the complaints received about animal welfare.”

Continue Reading
Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

News

Man arrested for illegal fishing in Teifi valley

Published

on

A MAN has been arrested after environmental crime officers from Natural Resources Wales (NRW) spotted an illegal net in a mid-Wales river.

The officers were conducting a routine patrol of the River Teifi on Thursday (May 14) when they came across a net in the water.

Following an investigation carried out in partnership with Dyfed Powys Police, a man was arrested on suspicion of illegal fisheries offences in the Teifi valley.

At the scene, officers retrieved the net which contained seven dead sea trout.

David Lee, NRW’s North and Mid Wales Operations Team Leader, said:

“Thanks to the excellent work of our officers and Dyfed Powys Police we were able to prevent further damage to the Teifi sea trout population.

“We take any activity that threatens sea trout and salmon extremely seriously and this is especially true of illegal fishing.

“Nets can potentially capture large numbers of fish and given the current challenges facing stock numbers currently every sea trout or salmon taken represents another blow to our efforts to protect these iconic fish.”

Despite the current Coronavirus lockdown, NRW officers are continuing to patrol Welsh rivers and people are encouraged to check that fish they buy locally – particularly through social media – are from a legitimate source.

If you see any suspicious or illegal activity on our rivers please report it to the NRW incident hotline on 0300 065 3000.

Continue Reading

News

Mother-daughter foot patrol brings 30 year career to a poignant end for Chief Inspector

Published

on

AS Chief Inspector Nicky Carter ended a 30 year career in policing, there was no better way to do it than going out on patrol with her daughter.

And for PCSO Charlotte, taking to the streets of Lampeter with her mum was a fitting way to mark her first six months at Dyfed-Powys Police.

Patrolling together in uniform was something the mother-daughter pair had long imagined, with PCSO Carter wanting to join the police from a young age.

The 19-year-old said: “I joined in September 2019, and have wanted to be a part of Dyfed-Powys Police since I can remember. I was inspired by my mum working in the force, and thought it would be a great career.

“I’m really glad I joined before she retired, as it gave us the opportunity to go out on foot patrol in the town where mum had been the local Inspector. It was really lovely.”

Embarking on a career she’d planned since childhood, PCSO Carter took the chance to gain valuable advice from her mum – whose experiences on the frontline inspired her to join.

“Mum has told me to always treat people as I would wish to be treated,” she said. “That’s something I’ll take forward with me.”

“I’m six months in now, and I enjoy dealing with the public and offering reassurance to people in the communities of Lampeter town and surrounding areas.”

For former CI Carter, the foot patrol drew a 30-year career – starting at North Wales Police – to a poignant close.

She ended her time at Dyfed-Powys Police in her home division of Ceredigion, transferring to Aberystwyth in 2006 to take up an inspector post.

Despite admitting there will be concerns for her only child as policing inevitably comes with risks, it was a career she encouraged.

She said: “I was very proud of Charlotte wishing to join Dyfed-Powys. As I retire I still consider that policing offers tremendous job satisfaction and I know that the organisation looks after and cares for its staff.

“I encouraged her to find out about the PCSO role before she applied, and also encouraged her to attend an open evening in Ceredigion to speak to staff. I wanted her to make an informed decision to join the organisation.

“As a parent and a former officer, it is natural to be concerned about what may occur when Charlotte is at work. However, the training, mentoring and support from staff and supervisors is second to none, so that offers me reassurance.”

Looking back at 30 years in policing, CI Carter has achieved plenty to inspire her daughter – and other women thinking of joining. From being a founding member of female networks in two forces, and a committee member of the British Association of Women in Policing, she has also proudly contributed to local and national work to ensure all staff reach their full potential.

She was humbled to receive a leadership award from Chwarae Teg in 2017, and represented chief officers at the International Association of Women Police awards in Alaska in 2019, where two Ceredigion officers were rewarded for their bravery.

When it comes to passing on her wealth of experience to her daughter, the former CI urged her to always consider her own wellbeing as well as that of the community.

“The most important advice I have given Charlotte is to look after herself and her wellbeing as whilst policing is a very rewarding role, it is one that can be both challenging and stressful at times,” she said.

Continue Reading

News

Ben Lake MP “disappointed” after Agriculture Bill amendment on the standard of food and agricultural imports is rejected by House of Commons

Published

on

The UK’s new Agriculture Bill was put before MPs on Wednesday (13 May) for the final time as it reached the Report Stage and Third Reading.

Alongside farming unions and campaign groups, Ben Lake MP has lobbied for the Bill to include a number of important amendments. One of the amendments sought to introduce a legal requirement that agricultural or food products imported into the UK under future trade agreements would need to be produced or processed according to equivalent animal health, welfare and environmental standards as those required of UK prodcuers.

This amendment, in the form of New Clause 2, and which was tabled by the Chair of the Environment, Food and Rural Affairs Committee Neil Parish MP, was rejected by the Commons. All Plaid Cymru MPs supported the amendment and Ben Lake MP said he was “disappointed” that the house did not vote in favour of an amendment to prevent the importation of products produced to lower animal health and environmental standards, and which in turn would have supported the high standards of Welsh produce.

Ben Lake MP said:

“Without this amendment there remains no legal requirement for future UK trade agreements to ensure that any agricultural or food imports are produced to the same standards as those required of domestic producers.

“Farmers in Wales strive to produce quality food in a sustainable manner, but the failure to include this amendment to the Agriculture Bill risks undermining these efforts by keeping the door open to imports produced to lower environmental and animal welfare standards.

“I have always argued that in order to protect our own high standards it is crucial that a level playing-field is maintained in relation to imports, and that farmers in Wales are not put at a disadvantage by having to compete with imports that are produced to lower standards. I sincerely hope that this amendment will be adopted by the House of Lords, so that the House of Commons has another opportunity to support it.”

Continue Reading

Popular This Week